46 Following


Currently reading

Blood Brothers: The Story of the Strange Friendship between Sitting Bull and Buffalo Bill
Deanne Stillman
Martin Luther: His Road to Reformation 1483-1521
Martin Brecht
Progress: 236/543 pages

A prime example of confirmation bias

The Politically Incorrect Guide to the Vietnam War - Phillip Jennings

This godawful book is best read as an example of confirmation bias. Jennings's goal in it is to show that 1) the U.S. won the Vietnam War 2) that Congress then lost it by "defenestrating" Nixon and abandoning South Vietnam in 1975. Along the way he argues that Ngo Dinh Diem was not such a bad guy, and that the South Vietnamese effort was undermined by delusional soldiers like John Paul Vann and agenda-driven reporters. To make these arguments, he has to ignore any pesky details that run counter to his own viewpoint (such as the brutality of French control over Vietnam and Eisenhower's manifest reluctance to intervene in 1954, to cite just two examples), as well as the mountain of evidence that supports them. It's not as if he lacked the space, as he apparently felt it necessary to pad out his account with a few descriptions of individual battles and an "interview" that reads as if it was conducted with himself in an echo chamber. It all makes for a lousy book, one that does a disservice to the argument he is attempting to make.